Found it!

I love when I find some­thing that I for­got that I was look­ing for…

I used to search for this song at every record store I vis­it­ed from around 1996–2000. It was not a new song at the time, but I real­ly want­ed it on 7-inch. Amoe­ba Records in San Fran­cis­co had a cor­ner filled with shelves which were filled with long box­es of Jamaican sin­gles and I would flip blind­ly through those records, not real­ly know­ing much about most of them.

I nev­er found the record.

But today I stum­bled on the song again in mp3 form! An old old itch has final­ly been scratched.

Sim­ple­ton — Coca Cola Shape